So I Loved: Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014)

Finally. After a handful of good movies , a single great one and some bad ones, we have the MCU's first truly Brilliant movie.

You can tell this film is singularly unique because no other entry would bother asking "Hey, wait, it's kinda weird that SHIELD had a mobile, aerial war machine, right?" as its main question. I neglected to mention it in my review of The Avengers but I did find it kinda uncomfortable how it basically ignores the implications of The Super CIA having what amounts to a movable Fort Knox that could be deployed to nuke basically anywhere on Earth. In general that movie sorta fellates SHIELD in a way that really exacerbates every problem the MCU had with the concept of American militarism.

Well, here, the driving question of the plot is the incredibly awful implications of Helicarriers. SHIELD has, like any branch of the US Government, evolved into its final form: A surveilance state. I'm actually gonna skip giving you an overview to instead back up and address a fairly common critique I've seen of the movie; in days gone by I've seen people say that HYDRA being the true villains of the movie and not SHIELD torpedoes the points that are being made about surveilance states, critique of the Obama Administration's "pre-emptive" drone strikes, the notion of a "pre-criminal" and freedom, and on some level I get them. The Nazis are so deeply evil that any action taken against them is ontologically good and anything they support is ontologically bad.
…I think what's being missed, though, is that the Nazis weren't a one-off thing and they weren't staffed by daemons spawned from hell. They were staffed by people, many of whom got Paperclip'd over to the US for a fresh start regardless of how they felt about the big R. HYDRA may be Nazis but the underlying motif of the film is that American exceptionalism, the War On Terror and a perpetual fear of American leadership as being seen as "soft on crime" have essentially led the country into the arms of fascism anyway. What's being missed, then, is that the goals of the USA align so heavily with the Nazis that nobody even noticed HYDRA until it's too late. The alien invasion from Avengers was the perfect cover, too. Nick Fury is their enemy and even he was happily espousing the benefits of That Shit From The Minority Report to a deeply uncomfortable Steve! SHIELD, no matter how good their intentions, were always going to evolve into a Gestapo. A culture of fear is always going to become a culture of control. A nation built on the idea of an eternal enemy was always going to make one up if the well went dry.

But enough about that, let's talk about the actual movie.

In the last Cap movie he embodied America in many ways, but on a meta level he embodied it by being one of their favourite genres: World War 2 period pieces. So, in a sense, it's appropriate that the freshly unfrozen Steve embodies America by starring in one of their new favourites: Political thrillers. Metatextually, this being a film primarily about Steve's gnawing isolation from modernity is served by SHIELD - whom the audience have been trained to unconditionally view as an ally - no longer being the overarching antagonist, removing a lot of certainty they provided in other movies. Seemingly calm scenes are punctured by sudden invasions, gunshots or other left-fielders and it gives the movie a fairly unsettling pace that wouldn't be out of place in a horror movie. If you blocked out the movie's events on a timeline it wouldn't really be all that different from other MCU movies (quiet scene > tense scene > tension boils over > action scene > repeat) but that this format is basically invisible during the actual watch speaks to some excellent craftsmanship. Doubly so because I am two and a half phases deep into this film series and it's normally impossible to turn off my structural critique brain.

And trust me, structurally the film is airtight. Good cinematography isn't new to MCU - albeit, it's not standard - but this is something else. Lots of long, beautiful shots and excellent framing. They know when to make Steve seem like a colossus and when to make him human, and while the action scenes do use a bit too much shaky cam, they're still of infinitely better composition than nearly every other action thriller from this period. If you're an attentive viewer there's a lot of fun blink-and-you-miss it moments like the cops ramming Fury from the side of his blind eye, Nat having bought all of Steve's gum immediately before the coming reveal, Bartoc and Steve being clad in darkness during their respective stints as black ops government goons, the SHIELD logo being a Nazi eagle rather than an American one, so on so forth. If I had to reach a little, I'd say the film's cinematography rules because it clearly takes some cues from tokusatsu. Things like Bucky getting to strike a gay little pose and have an epic intro motif before he starts shooting add a lot of flavour that even the better MCU movies lacked.

The action of course deserves its own segment. 'Good action' in the MCU typically means a blend of practical and CGI, but here it's predominantly practical effects and fights with incredible choreography. Chris Evans really puts in work and brings to Steve a combination of grace, agility and frightening power. One of The Avenger's worst failings - and proof Whedon never really bothered to check what he was following up on - was that Steve ended up just being A Guy. Here he's very much superhuman, but on the lower end of the scale so he still has to actually fight his opponents. He does some incredible spins and flips while still moving against most of the unenhanced human enemies like they were goons in a Batman Arkham game. There's a reason everyone who watches these movies inherently knows what you mean when you say "elevator scene".
But the real highlight are the moments where Steve is facing down someone who can give him a fair fight. The film uses these pretty sparingly but that just makes them all the sweeter. Sebastian Stan and Georges St Pierre both move like demons and they clash about Evans so convincingly that, upon finding out Bucky's gay little knife trick during their first fight was entirely real and that Sebastian Stan actually did it, I didn't even question it. Having sat through so many movies where the best parts are mostly CGI it's frankly refreshing to see Steve fight off his best friend with help from his new queerplatonic bestie and boyfriend and have it be… You know. People actually fighting. When Steve fights Bartoc it's two acrobatic beasts fighting on even footing but when Bucky shows up there's an air of manic desperation even when Steve's winning.
Bucky is actually the best instrument with which to measure the fight choreography because they've accounted for his arm as a physical force and thus he moves completely differently to everyone else. That arm is clearly a heavy, bulky and uncomfortable thing so despite being brainwashed he actively avoids trying to use it during knife fights and only ever breaks it out for devastating hits or to protect himself. In many ways, it moves like a semi-sentient parasite, always lurching up to cover his face or crush somehow yet limp and inert when he's not killing. Between this movie and John Wick, 2014 was good for action movies.

Superhero movies, Shonen, Tokusatsu and almost all relatively-optimistic art centered around a heroic figure are ultimately magic shows. They're trying to sell you on an illusion that the hero might not win, that the fights they take part in may end in defeat, and that it's an uphill battle. Consciously, you already know they're going to win. It's just a fact, one further reinforced by Hero Art almost universally being centered around toy and merchandise sales post-hoc.
Where The Winter Soldier succeeds is in successfully selling its own stakes and tension. It's basically impossible to go into this without knowing Age of Ultron is next and that Steve will return alongside Nat, but the individual encounters and overarching threat are reinforced so well that, for a few moments, it almost seems like there's a very real risk Steve will fail. If we want to get technical, the overarching threat of this movie is ultimately lower in scale than the ones in Thor Dark World or The Avengers, but it feels so much more tangible than in those movies.

But, you know, I could live without all that.

What makes this film so good is that it's the first MCU movie to actually nail character writing without falling into the usual pitfalls of either making the protagonist an unfailing ubermensch or turning his love interest into a caretaker, in part because this time the love interest is mostly off-screen.

Much has been said about everyone else in this movie but I'll confess that I was infinitely more taken with Sam on this rewatch than I was before. Being much older it's easier to notice that their meet-cute in the opening scene is less of a chill bro moment and more Sam quietly nudging Steve to go to fucking therapy already. He clearly doesn't buy Steve's obvious lies that he's settling in just fine and his introduction to the actual plot is an unsubtle attempt to keep an eye on a man who is clearly traumatized by his entire world being gone and coping by throwing himself into war. His joke about showing up to the Veterans Affairs office to act as a wingman for a woman is so very obviously an attempt to get Steve into counselling that I'm ashamed I missed it the first time. Anthony Mackie also brings a pretty phenomenal and natural performance to the film that I'm suddenly really upset all this enthusiasm gradually gets burned out of him over the IRL runtime of the MCU. No wonder he's so annoyed on the set of the latest Cap film.

And man. Natasha/Black Widow has an actual character now. Can you believe that? In the MCU for 90% of its existence and she's only just now displaying real personality traits. In previous movies she was either a stoic sex object an imperiled badass who only ever moved in a way that Joss Whedon could jerk off to. Here she's Steve bestie/caretaker but avoids the problems both roles often face in the MCU, where the bestie is the only sane man and the caretaker fulfills an oedipal role. She banters with him and is quite clearly attracted to him but, like he and Sam, falters when she realizes just how out of her depth is and just how much she's been lied to. She's as tough as she is fragile, but her fragility is portrayed as an understandable reaction to her new life being a lie rather than the fetishistic way she'll be vulnerable in Age of Ultron. When she takes part in the action scenes she finally gets to show off what being a super spy actually entails, and this is one of the few MCU movies where a character whose main combat trait is 'smart' actually gets to be crafty. Also her dynamic with Steve is really good, lots of push-pull and playful banter, it's like Tony and Pepper's relationship but not weird. I don't think they're romantically entwined but they definitely fucked. Right? Right? Come on now.

Steve himself is maybe the star of the show if only because the writers were clearly offended by Whedon turning him into a 2pure4u boyscout who would never even swear. Steve is a bitter man, clearly struggling in a world that's left him behind and haunted by the years he missed. He habitually lies to people attempting to get close to him and is a master of deflection. Having fought in a war where he could claim, unambiguously, that he was on "the right side", he's now acting as the attack dog for an obviously corrupt and deeply shady organization that's still looking over its shoulder in response to the Cold War. He can be affable and even charming but it's so obviously a front that it makes Tony's attempts to hide his PTSD in Iron Man 3 seem subtle. I dogged on Thor 2 for not really having character development, and in a sense Steve doesn't really have any either, if only because his character development is more on the negative side. Steve is quite blatantly suicidal for most of this movie and it's only when he sees Bucky does he become motivated, but this motivation is less that of a hero and moreso of a man zeroing on something familiar in the hopes that it squares the circle of his impossible life. It's… Sad, man. It's really fucking sad.

There is one teensy-tiny part of the movie that I don't like, one so bad that it does kinda betray the invisible hand of the DoD behind a film otherwise free of it, and that's the torture scene on top of the roof.

Yes, it's funny. Yes, it is a great moment for Steve and Nat. Yes, it's phenomenally well-acted like the rest of the movie… But also it's still a torture scene in a political thriller so it stumbles into basically every unfortunate implication imaginable. Sitwell, a deep-cover HYDRA agent, breaks after a single scare and divulges 100% truthful information that is completely accurate and not tainted by fear or a desire to preserve the lives of his allies. Steve, Nat and Sam don't even consider the ethical implications of succumbing to torture just because the guy is evil enough to deserve it and this is wildly OOC for Steve especially given he spends the entire first half of the movie opposing Project Insight for being too far in the direction of an evil amoral surveilance state that justifies atrocities "for the greater good". There's also some strange cognitive dissonance going on wherein Steve and co.'s torture is portrayed as good, justified and righteous, but HYDRA's torture of Bucky is evil, despite them both being torturers. Like… Steve… You can't tell Nick Fury you don't wanna be the bad guys only to then turn around and torture a guy for information on the bad guys.

It's a weird scene. Don't like it. Tonally at odds with the rest of the movie and is quite obviously a way to stop the plot's wheels from spinning. Doesn't stop it being the best MCU movie and then some but it leaves a sour taste in the mouth.

Guardians of the Galaxy next, which should be a fun time, but then there's Age of Ultron straight into Civil War… Not looking forward to it.